DMG MORI: THE STRUGGLES FROM WITHIN (JAPANESE VS. GERMAN SPINDLES)
Many people ask who makes the best CNC Machine Tools in the world. More specifically who manufactures the best CNC Spindles and who provides the best service for these machine tool spindles. DMG Mori is at the top of the list for all categories. Before I explain further let’s take a closer look at a brief history of DMG Mori so you understand how they became who they are today and how I’ve been so closely involved with this company for decades.
For those of you not familiar some background is in order. DMG Mori is a powerhouse CNC Machine Tool Manufacturer specializing in the sale of CNC Machining Centers and CNC Turning Centers in the world.
DMG Mori was formerly two separate companies: DMG and Mori Seiki. The merger occurred in 2010 to form DMG Mori Seiki. Later in 2013 they dropped the “Seiki” to become DMG Mori.
Many of us in the CNC machine tool industry thought the merger was odd as DMG’s origin is German and Mori Seiki’s is Japanese. These origins may have had an influence on DMG Mori’s selection of multiple spindle suppliers.
A Look at DMG & Kessler:
German machine tool manufacturers are known for outsourcing the supply of their new CNC spindles and spindle repair services. Frequently new spindles are stocked at the OEMs facility for exchanges or shipped in for repair. Over the years DMG has relied heavily on Kessler for the supply of their CNC spindles. Kessler is a German based company and the largest spindle manufacturer in the world. If you own a German Machining Center or Turning Center in the USA chances are highly likely you are running a Kessler spindle. These spindles are known for their high speed, high torque and high metal removal capabilities.
Kessler USA is located in Plymouth, MI. Kessler spindles are highly respected for quality and precision. The installation of Kessler spindles in the USA has exploded in the last few decades creating a high demand for more and more spindle repairs years after year. Support for Kessler spindle repair service is sometimes difficult.
If you question the validity of that last statement I have a question for you:
Why does Kessler USA have their sole service facility in Plymouth, MI and another Certified spindle repair company less than two dozen miles away? (That’s a topic for another day).
Now Let’s Take a Look at Mori Seiki Spindles:
Japanese Machine Tool OEMs are known to manufacture their spindles in house and rebuild their own spindles. Mori Seiki was known for their industry leading metal removal rates with their in house manufactured spindles.
Did the combined origins of DMG Mori having roots in both Germany and Japan create an internal struggle as to who should supply their CNC spindles?
Is DMG Mori best to manufacture spindles exclusively in Japan or outsource the supply of new spindles to Kessler Germany?
Should DMG Mori partner with a spindle repair company to meet the growing demand of their customers in America?
Mr. Kazutoyo Moriguchi the President of DMG Mori USA based out of Davis, CA and I discussed the questions above. At first I suspected his visit may be only a formality. Then as he began to explain their ongoing challenges to keep up with a growing demand for such a high volume of spindles I began to understand the severity of this situation made increasingly more difficult because of their successful sale and diversity of their product line. Bear in mind DMG Mori sells both CNC Machining Centers and Turning Centers with more than 160,000 machine tool installations worldwide.
As our conversation moved from our conference room to the shop floor of our 25,000 sq.ft Spindle Remanufacturing facility I understood their need for help was real. Mr. Moriguchi and I talked for hours about the ever present challenges of peaks and valleys both of our customers ever changing requirements create. Often people speak of “feast of famine” in the machine tool industry. For DMG Mori and Motor City Spindle Repair this is not the case. It’s more of a strategy on how to handle our continuous models of growth. There are no slow periods. Not even in this pandemic. Only periods of how to best manage customer demands. At Motor City Spindle we deal with challenges of processing 40 to 50 spindles in a slow month to processing multiple stages of spindle repair exceeding 100 spindles in a busy month. Imagine what DMG Mori is faced with keeping spindles on hand for all new CNC machine tool sales but also all “Legacy” machine tool spindles.
Legacy spindles is a term used to describe a spindle from machines an OEM no longer sells but is still contacted frequently to support for service. Imagine the difficulty of keeping up with these constant requests.
I learned the term “Legacy” spindles to describe Mori Seiki spindles from Edward Dee who I hired in 2018 to work in our Spindle Room. Ed worked for DMG Mori in their Dallas, TX Spindle Room. Years ago DMG Mori rebuilt their spindles in Dallas, TX before moving it Davis, CA. It is rumored there are several hundreds of spindles (I even heard 800 to 1000) at the Dallas, TX facility in need of repair but the need of what quantities are nearly impossible to calculate. I can’t help but think of the ending to Raiders of Lost Ark when they wheel that crate containing the “Ark” to its final resting place.
Really, several hundred broken spindles? 200? 500? 800? 1000? Will these broken spindles ever be rebuilt? Will DMG Mori ever load up semi trucks full of broken spindles and ship them to The Motor City Spindle Team? (I serious doubt it but that’s another topic for another day).
ENOUGH BACK STORY. ENOUGH HISTORY. ANSWER THE QUESTIONS!!!!
WHO MAKES THE BEST CNC MACHINE TOOLS IN THE WORLD?
My answer is DMG MORI. Hands down they are my #1. They may not be your #1.
You may be a bigger fan of Mazak, Okuma, MAG, Grob, Kitamura, Enshu, Fives, Doosan or countless others. If so, I’d love to more from you and why.
WHO MAKES THE BEST CNC SPINDLE IN WORLD?
DMG MORI / Japan
Kessler Germany
WHO PROVIDES THE BEST CNC SPINDLE REPAIR SERVICE IN THE WORLD?
Motor City Spindle Repair. Look at the reasons below and you have to agree:
- Hired (4) Spindle Technicians from Kessler USA & one from DMG Mori
- We have never lost a single Key Employee in the history of our Company
- Own the Largest Independent Spindle Repair Facility in the USA
- All (3) Owners worked for a Major Spindle OEM
- All Senior Spindle Room Assembly Technicians have over 20 Years Experience
- We understand Customer Service and always put the customer first
My name is Ted Ladzinski and I own Motor City Spindle Repair. I have been fortunate enough to work directly with DMG Mori to service CNC spindles but please allow me to be clear:
Motor City Spindle Repair is not an authorized spindle repair vendor for DMG Mori nor Kessler. I am the proud owner of an American Spindle Repair company rebuilding Japanese and German Spindles to support American Manufacturing. Our TEAM Knows CNC Spindles!
Schedule a tour by calling us at 734-261-8600 or emailing sales@motorcityrepair.com
Call us at (734) 261-8600 or email us at Sales@motorcityrepair.com to learn more.
157+ Years of Experience In Our Spindle Room Serving the Largest Corporations in the USA
Aerospace
Automotive
Agriculture
Machine Tool
and many others
24/7 Emergency Repair Service + We Deliver.
Industry’s Most Aggressive 1-3 weeks for standard repairs
We will get your machine running in no time.
Dedicated staff available 24/7 to assist you with emergency spindle repair services.
We offer door-to-door pickup and delivery on our emergency repair services.
We Repair Depending On Your Need.
Guaranteed Cost Savings as we have in-house machining and grinding capabilities
8 Full Time Technicians in our spindle room
Balanced, Test Run, and Certified with A Full 1 Year Warranty
Spindles are test run at maximum RPM, while performing vibration & temperature analysis.
Bearings are checked for velocity & displacement.
All electrical components are tested, repaired and replaced as needed.
Dynamic & Static Balancing of Spindles at maximum RPM.
Repair specialists for your Motorized or Belt Driven machines:
Horizontal Machining Centers
Vertical Machining Centers
Turning Centers
Grinding Machines
Any other machine tools
We offer the following spindle upgrades:
Air Purge
Ceramic Bearings
New Bearing Configuration
Encapsulate Motor Windings
Retrofit spindle shaft with removable drive keys
We specialize in Fanuc Servo Motor Repair, including:
i series
DiS series
ALPHA series
BETA Series
ROBODRILL series
- Motor City Spindle Repair has 157+ Years Experience in Our Spindle Room
- 24/7 Emergency Spindle Repair Services
- Eight Full Time Spindle Assembly Technicians
- Free Evaluations and Free Delivery Services
- All Spindles Certified and Tested with a Full 1 Year Warranty
- Free Estimates Over the Phone in Seconds
- In House Machining and Grinding Capabilities
- On-site Spindle Repair Service
- Currently performing 60-70 Spindles In House Per Month
Example of a Weiss Machining Center Spindle Rebuilt in house by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a Kessler Machining Center Spindle Rebuilt in house by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a Mazak Machining Center Spindle Rebuilt in house by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of an NTC Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a Kessler Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a Kira Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a Fuji Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of Machining Center Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a Kessler Machining Center Spindle In house by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of Enshu Spindles Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
This is our new 25,000 sq.ft Spindle Remanufacturing Facility.
Example of a Doosan Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Our Spindle Room has (8) Full time assembly technicians that average nearly 20 years experience
CNC Spindle Repair Services
CNC Spindle Repair Delivery Services
Example of Hermle Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of Kessler Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a Hardinge Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a Hessapp Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a Weiss Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a OKK Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of Hermle Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of Kessler Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a Hardinge Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a Hessapp Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a Weiss Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a OKK Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a GMN Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a DMG Mori Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a Kessler Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Free spindle Repair Estimates
Example of a Fanuc Spindle Motor Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a Spindle Rebuilt and Tested by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of an NTC Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a Kessler Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a Kira Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a Fuji Spindle Repair Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of Machining Centers Spindle Repaired and Rebuilt by Motor City Spindle Repair
Example of a Kessler Machining Center Spindle In house by Motor City Spindle Repair